Symmetric Application Of Dynamic Scoring

Republicans are keen to sacrifice CBO's role as impartial arbiter of fiscal measures on the altar of “dynamic scoring” of tax measures.[0] But there is no economic reason for restricting this approach to only tax measures.

 

First, on tax measures, from Jane Gravelle in a Congressional Research Service review of the policy literature:

Economists were attracted to intertemporal models because they were dissatisfied with the ad hoc treatment of in Solow models. However, intertemporal models are far less transparent, and modelers appear in some cases to make little attempt to connect the elasticities associated
with labor supply to the ones found in empirical evidence. The JCT [Joint Committee on Taxation] model used in the past has come close but, as illustrated, it is possible to come even closer to matching the empirical evidence, while at the same time minimizing “shooting in the dark” with a labor supply response to the interest rate. JCT also incorporates life-cycle elements in their MEG [Macroeconomic Growth Model] model that do not involve labor supply responses to rates of return. Nevertheless, the assumption of equal substitution elasticities between consumption across far apart periods means that these models still rest on unproven, and probably unreasonable assumptions about the elasticity of substitution between consumption amounts that are ten or twenty years apart. There is a question of whether intertemporal models do more harm than good, at least with respect to the feedback effects during the budget horizon, especially when parameter choices may induce a large labor supply response to the rate of return.

Intertemporal modelers presenting the background on their models sometimes report the first two values in Table 4 but no measure of the leisure share of time, which makes it impossible to evaluate on the basis of their published work. Sometimes even the minimal information on elasticities is not provided. (JCT and CBO report all their relevant assumptions.) Without the parameters to understand the models (and particularly without information on the time endowment), these models become impossible to evaluate or compare.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
No tags for this post.

Related posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *